5. Where are you now?

When considering the development of a CRM programme in your institution, a critical first step is to make an honest assessment of your current position.

Three different stages of maturity in CRM practice in HEIs have been identified (The  KSA Partnership, 2007, p.6).

  • Peripheral - isolated incidences of CRM usage, mainly to manage contacts, with no integration with other institutional systems

  • Tactical - multiple incidences of CRM usage to inform service delivery and improvement, with some integration with other institutional systems

  • Strategic – institution-wide use of CRM across all business units to inform strategic management of relationships, fully integrated with other institutional systems; cross-institutional BCE partner relationship management with other institutions at the same stage.

In fact, the different stages can be viewed as a continuum as shown by the diagram below.

 

CRM defined narrowly and tactically

     

CRM defined broadly and strategically

 
* * *
 

*

 

*

 

*

 
 

CRM is about the implementation of a specific technology solution project

 

CRM is the implementation of an integrated series of customer-oriented technology solutions

 

CRM is a holistic approach to managing customer relationships in order to create shareholder value

 

The CRM continuum (Payne, 2006)

Where are you now?

The diagram below can be used to assess the present position of your institution with respect to the development of CRM

Uptake across institution's business units

*

All business units across the institution (academic schools, BCE unit and other relevant support services) use the CRM system on a routine basis

   

Strategic

 

BCE unit and some business units across the university (acadenuc schools and other relevant support services) use the CRM system on a routine basis

 

Tactical

 
*



BCE unit and/or central team uses the CRM system on a routine basis


Peripheral

   
     

BCE relationships managed; no/little integration with other institutional systems; multiple instance/record of customer data

BCE relationships managed; integration with some other institutional systems; movement towards a single incidence of customer data

BCE relationships managed; full integration with relevant institutional systems; single instance/record of customer data

*

 

*

Functions / functional integration

The horizontal axis represents the breadth of the functions or BCE services/activities managed by the CRM system.

The vertical axis represents the level of uptake of the CRM system across the institution’s business units.

Where are you now?

  • To help you assess more accurately where you are at present,the following descriptors might help.

  • The left hand descriptors are typical of an institution in the early stages of development of a CRM. The right hand descriptors are typical of a more mature development.

  • Look at each descriptor. Where do you think you are now?

Covers a limited range of BCE services

>

Covers full range of BCE services

Narrow range of transaction types supported

>

Wide range of transaction types supported

Multiple instances of customer

>

Single instance/record of customer

Supports interaction with a narrow range of customer types

>

Supports interactions with a wide range of customer types

Single business unit uses the system on a routine basis

>

Multiple business unit uses the system on a routine basis

Limited/no integration with other HEI function

>

Full integration with other HEI functions

Limited/no integration with other relevant institutional systems

>

Full integration with other relevant institutional systems

Provides basic customer needs to support operational activity

>

Provides client intelligence to inform strategic decision making/planning

HEI-centric

>

Customer-centric

Read a description of an HEI moving from peripheral to tactical

Read a description of an HEI moving from tactical to strategic

Where would you like to be?

The diagram below  can be used to plan where you would like to move to in terms of being more tactical or strategic in your approach to CRM.

Remember: The horizontal axis represents the breadth of functions managed by the CRM system. The vertical axis represents the extent of uptake across the institution.

The arrows show the possible routes an institution might take to move from peripheral to tactical to strategic deployment of the CRM system.

Routes to CRM

What approach to implementation will you take?

There are four main implementation approaches:

  • Sudden or ‘big bang’ approach

    The big bang approach

  • Parallel approach

    The parallel approach

  • Phased approach

    The phased approach

  • Pilot approach

    The pilot approach

The appropriateness of each model will depend on the circumstances of your institution. You do not have to move from peripheral straight to strategic. Many developers/consultancies advise on a phased approach so that the organization can get accustomed to the changes and any difficulties can be resolved without huge consequences to the entire organization.


More detail on each of the models can be found in JISC infoNet System Implementation www.jiscinfonet.ac.uk/InfoKits/system-implementation/planning/implementation-models

Key points to remember about planning a CRM implementation

Tick box

Three stages of maturity in CRM practice have been identified – peripheral, tactical and strategic

Tick box

Use the case studies and descriptors to determine your present position

Tick box

Plan where you want to move to

Tick box

Be realistic in your aims. You do not have to move straight form Peripheral to strategic

Tick box

Choose an implementation model that suits your institution

Tick box

Use value maps to assess whether or not your institution is creating value for customers

 

Jump to another section